Artificial Intelligence (AI) is reshaping industries, revolutionizing how we build and interact with technology. But while companies pour resources into shiny, officially sanctioned AI systems, there's a growing movement happening under the radar: Shadow AI. These unsanctioned tools and systems represent the new frontier — a Wild West where innovation thrives, rules are bent, and risks abound.
What is Shadow AI?
Shadow AI includes any AI application or tool that operates outside an organization's IT or governance frameworks. Think shadow IT but with a lot more potential (and risk). It's the digital equivalent of prospectors staking their claims in the gold rush — cutting through red tape to strike it rich in efficiency and innovation. Examples include employees using ChatGPT to draft proposals, using new AI-powered code assistants, building machine learning models on personal accounts, or automating tedious tasks with unofficial scripts.
Why is Shadow AI emerging?
Shadow AI's rise isn't exactly shocking to those familiar with shadow IT. Here's why it's becoming a thing:
-
AI is everywhere: User-friendly platforms and tools make AI accessible to nearly everyone.
-
Need for speed: Official processes can be slow, so teams take the initiative, much like pioneers blazing trails in uncharted territories.
-
Remote work: Distributed teams often operate outside traditional oversight, like settlers far from the law.
-
Policy gaps: Many organizations lack comprehensive AI governance, leaving room for improvisation.
Lessons from the open source gold rush
Shadow AI's trajectory feels familiar. Remember the early days of open source? Developers turned to open source for faster, cheaper, and better software development — even when lawyers and security panicked over intellectual property, licensing, and security. Much like miners seeking gold, developers embraced open source to extract value, even if it meant taking risks.
Organizations initially tried to restrict open source use, but developers and commercial teams found workarounds. Over time, open source transitioned from outlaw tech to essential infrastructure, powering 90% of enterprise software today. Now, AI tools like ChatGPT and Copilot are following the same path. Developers are adopting them en masse, while security teams struggle to keep up. Trying to block AI adoption outright is like banning the gold rush — it won't stop the movement; it'll just shift it underground.
Opportunities and risks of Shadow AI
There are numerous opportunities when it comes to AI adoption. To name just a few:
-
Speed: Shadow AI helps teams implement solutions faster than traditional channels.
-
Experimentation: It allows for rapid prototyping and creative problem-solving, reminiscent of pioneers testing new lands.
-
Empowerment: Broader access to AI can drive innovation across all levels of an organization.
But those opportunities don't come without risks, and managing those risks will be critical to safe and successful use of AI. A few risks include:
-
Data vulnerabilities: Unapproved tools can expose sensitive information.
-
Compliance issues: Shadow AI could lead to unintentional violations of data regulations.
-
Quality concerns: Lack of oversight may result in poorly designed or biased AI models.
-
Operational chaos: Unregulated tools can create inefficiencies and redundancies.
-
Exploitation by bad actors: Without robust AI adoption, organizations risk being targeted by bad actors who use AI to scale phishing, fraud, and other attacks. Security teams must integrate AI into their defenses to stay ahead of these threats.
Managing the Shadow AI phenomenon
Organizations need to embrace the potential of Shadow AI while managing its risks. Here's how to tame this Wild West:
-
Establish clear policies: Define guidelines for AI usage, approved tools, and data handling practices.
-
Educate employees: Train staff on the risks and responsibilities of AI use.
-
Provide sanctioned platforms: Offer accessible, approved environments for AI experimentation.
-
Monitor and audit: Use tools to detect and manage unauthorized AI applications.
-
Encourage collaboration: Foster partnerships among IT, data science, and business units for responsible AI adoption.
-
Invest in AI for security: Proactively adopting AI-powered security tools can help detect and counter threats from malicious actors leveraging AI.
The future of Shadow AI
AI isn't a passing trend, and Shadow AI is only going to evolve. Organizations can either fight the tide or learn to ride the wave. Much like taming the Wild West, businesses that develop smart strategies can transform Shadow AI from a chaotic frontier into a thriving, well-governed landscape. Balance and proactive communication will be key to making Shadow AI work for — not against — your business.
To stay ahead in this rapidly evolving AI landscape, organizations need visibility and control over their software supply chain — including the AI tools developers use and the AI components being integrated into software. Sonatype helps teams harness the power of AI safely by providing automated governance, security, and compliance for AI-driven development. Learn how Sonatype can support your AI strategy here.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5efac/5efacba439dee4defbacc9909061781d70591107" alt="Picture of Mitchell Johnson"
Written by Mitchell Johnson
Mitchell has more than 25 years of experience as a developer, architect, team-builder and leader across a variety of high-growth roles in technology, data, product, and mergers and acquisitions, including stints at eVestment a Nasdaq Company, Equifax, Grant Thornton and Delta Air Lines. Mitchell ...
Related Resources
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a42ad/a42adebdff0fe4afb5b3623030cfebb5bd6d4e03" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/fd077/fd077bcf452f52d52b3c4106f9295a5fdd187bf7" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/dc03c/dc03c85f7429594c898665e1d04480b6982a01bd" alt="Sonatype Developer video showcasing the Developer Dashboard"